You’ve got a great product idea, and you’re ready to start selling online, but here’s the million-dollar question: Should you set up shop on Etsy or Shopify?
Selling on Shopify can build you a real, profitable brand, while on Etsy, you can reach potential customers very quickly.
Here’s the thing: You don’t want to waste months building on the wrong platform, only to realize you’re leaving money on the table.
Maybe you’re worried about expensive monthly fees eating into profits you haven’t even made yet, or you’re concerned about investing time into a platform that won’t scale with your business.
The Etsy vs Shopify decision isn’t about which one is “better”; it’s about which one fits your goals right now.
The Etsy comparison shows clear winners depending on whether you’re just testing product ideas or ready to build a real brand.
In this post, I’m going to walk you through exactly when to use Etsy, when to use Shopify, and how to actually make money with your online store using Shopify and Etsy strategically.
By the end, you’ll know exactly which platform to start with and how to sell products profitably from day one.
What is Shopify and how does it work
Shopify is an e-commerce platform that lets you build and run your own online store without knowing how to code. Think of it like renting a complete storefront, website builder, checkout system, and all the tech stuff handled for you.
Here’s how it works: You sign up, choose a theme (there are free options), and customize your store using a simple drag-and-drop editor. Once your store looks good, you add your products, set your prices, and connect a payment method.
Shopify provides everything you need in one dashboard, no jumping between different services for hosting, payment processing, or security.
When someone buys from your store, Shopify processes the payment securely, sends you a notification, updates your inventory automatically, and helps you fulfill the order.
You can sell physical products or digital downloads, the whole process is easy and beginner-friendly.
The platform runs on a monthly subscription, and you get access to thousands of apps that add features such as email marketing, abandoned cart recovery, and advanced analytics.
What is Etsy and how does it work
Etsy is a marketplace where independent sellers can open a shop and sell handmade items, print-on-demand products (like t-shirts and mugs), digital products, craft supplies, and more. Think of it like your stall in a farmers market, but online, there are already millions of shoppers browsing Etsy every month searching for products.
Here’s how it works as an Etsy seller: You create a free account, set up your Etsy shop by adding a shop name and branding, then start listing products. You write a product title, add photos, set your price, and include keywords so shoppers can find your items when they search.
The big benefit about Etsy marketplace is that customers are already there searching for products like yours. When someone buys from your shop, Etsy handles the payment, and you pay Etsy fees. You’re responsible for making the product, packaging it, and getting it to the customer.
Unlike building your own website, everything happens inside the Etsy platform, you don’t need to worry about hosting, security, or driving traffic from scratch.
The tradeoff is that you are selling on another platform, not your own, which means you will pay higher fees, follow their rules, and constantly compete with other sellers selling the same product you are (and I will dive into this later in this post).
Shopify vs Etsy for Beginners
If you’ve never sold anything online before, Etsy is better suited to complete beginners, no question about it.
Here’s why: You don’t need to build a website from scratch. With Etsy, you just create an account, set up your shop profile, upload your product photos, write descriptions, and you’re basically ready to sell.
Whereas Etsy handles all the technical stuff (hosting, security, checkout systems) for you, Shopify is a platform where you’re building your own standalone website. You need to choose a theme, set up payment gateways, and set up shipping; there’s just more to figure out before you can start selling.
Shopify isn’t complicated if you’re willing to put in a few extra hours to learn what you need to sell on the platform. They have set up wizards and 24/7 support to help you through it. But if you just want to start selling today, Etsy makes it incredibly easy.
Although it’s easier to start, Etsy gives you less control over how your store looks and functions, and you are basically ‘renting’ space in their marketplace. But if you just want to throw a few products out there for now and see if they sell, then it’s easier to start on Etsy.
Etsy vs Shopify for digital products
The difference between Etsy and Shopify for digital products depends heavily on what you’re selling and your price point.
If you’re selling high-ticket digital products, like ebooks priced at $27, online courses at $197, or comprehensive design bundles at $99, then Shopify is going to be way more profitable.
On Etsy, you’re paying around 10% in combined fees per sale (6.5% transaction fee plus payment processing). That means if you sell a $100 course, Etsy takes about $10. On Shopify, you’re only paying credit card processing fees (around 2.9% + 30¢) and a fixed subscription fee (which does not depend on your sales). Those extra dollars add up fast when you’re selling higher-priced items.
For low-ticket digital products like templates and printables under $10, marketplaces like Etsy that only charge you fees per transaction work better. The percentage fees hurt less when your sale price is low anyway.
⇒ Free Etsy Profit Calculator for Digital Products
But here’s the real risk with selling digital products on Etsy that most people don’t talk about: competitors can buy your template, copy it, tweak it slightly, and resell it for half your price.
And you’ll probably never track them or report them to Etsy, because they can sign up with a completely different email address and purchase your product as a regular customer.
There’s no way to track who’s downloading your files, copying them, and reselling them.
Unfortunately, I have experienced it myself: I had a best-seller template that I worked on a lot, copied and slightly changed with colors, and was selling for a third of the price I’m selling. Extremely frustrating. If I were selling these templates on my own Shopify store, that could never happened.
Shopify vs Etsy for print on demand Sellers
For print-on-demand sellers, the platform you choose directly impacts your profit margins.
Ease of starting: With Etsy, you can be up and running quickly with POD integrations like Printful or Printify, which are already built into the platform. Shopify requires more setup when connecting your POD app and setting up taxes and payments, but once it’s done, it’s done.
Competition: On Etsy, your products sit right next to dozens (sometimes hundreds!) of similar designs. When someone searches for “funny dog shirt,” they see 100 options at once.
Customers most often choose from the options shown on the first page and select a product based on price or reviews. On Shopify, customers only see your store and your products, no one else’s, which is a HUGE benefit.
Pricing power: On your own Shopify store, you can charge $32 for a t-shirt because customers can’t compare it to someone else’s $18 version sitting two inches away on the screen. On Etsy, on the other hand, shoppers comparison-shop constantly, which pushes prices down. It’s harder to justify premium pricing when buyers can see cheaper alternatives instantly.
Profits: Once you’re selling a few hundred dollars a month, Shopify becomes way more profitable. Etsy takes roughly 10% in combined fees per sale. On a $500 month, that’s $50 gone. Shopify’s monthly fee plus minimal transaction fees (around 2.9%) means you keep significantly more of each sale. The math flips in Shopify’s favor fast once volume increases.
⇒ How to Start a Print on Demand Business – Step by Step Guide!
Comparing Shopify vs Etsy for Artists
If you create handmade goods or original art, Etsy feels like it was built for you. The platform attracts buyers specifically searching for unique, handcrafted items with a story behind them, people who value supporting small artists and makers.
When you sell handmade items on Etsy, you’re tapping into over 90 million active buyers who are already looking for something special and customized.
Shopify, on the other hand, gives you complete creative control over how your brand looks and feels. You can design your website to match your artistic style, tell your story however you want, and build a recognizable brand identity that stands out across all social media platforms and in Google search results.
For artists who’ve already built a following on Instagram or an email list, Shopify lets you direct those fans to a store that’s entirely yours and continue building trust and relationships with your customers.
With Shopify, you’ll need to drive your own traffic, but if you’re serious about building a long-term art business and want full ownership over your customer relationships, then Shopify is worth the extra effort.
Shopify Fees vs Etsy Fees
Let’s break down exactly what each platform charges, because these fees directly impact how much money you actually keep.
Etsy
Etsy charges a $0.20 listing fee every time you publish a product (whether it sells or not), and listings renew after four months. When you make a sale, Etsy takes a 6.5% transaction fee on the total order amount, including the item price, shipping, and gift wrapping.
On top of that, Etsy Payments charges a payment processing fee of around 3% + $0.25 per transaction.When you add everything up, Etsy keeps a minimum of 10% of the total order value, before additional payments like Etsy off-site ads.
Shopify
Shopify has a monthly fee that starts at $29 for the Basic plan (if you pay annually). Shopify charges credit card processing fees (2.9% + 30¢ on the Basic plan), which is called Shopify Payments, and there are no additional transaction fees.
The math changes fast once you’re selling more than a few hundred dollars a month. With Etsy, those percentage-based fees add up on every single sale.
With Shopify, you’re paying that flat monthly fee plus minimal processing charges, which means you keep significantly more profit as your sales grow.
Free Trials and Plans – Shopify vs Etsy Comparison
Shopify Pricing Plans
Here are the 3 main plans when billed annually:
1) Basic Plan: $29/month (billed annually), includes unlimited products, 24/7 support for your questions, abandoned cart recovery, and all the features you need to start selling your products online. A great option for new stores.
2) Grow Plan: $79/month (billed annually)- this is mainly for more established businesses. You get additional features, such as using gift cards, generating professional reports, and more.
3) Advanced Plan: $299/month (billed annually)- for more advanced stores with high-volume sales. You get lower transaction fees and additional advanced features.
For enterprises making millions in revenue, Shopify offers the Shopify Plus plan (Starting at $2,000/month).
Shopify special offer: a 3-day free trial + $ 1/month for 3 months! So you have plenty of time to test the platform.
Etsy Plans
Etsy offers two simple options:
Standard Plan (Free): No monthly subscription fee. You only pay when you list products ($0.20 per listing) and when you make sales (transaction fees). This works for most sellers just getting started.
Etsy Plus ($10/month): You get 15 free listing credits, $5 in Etsy Ads credits monthly, advanced shop customization with custom banners and shop sections, restock request alerts, and discounts on custom web addresses and promotional materials.
It gives you more customization options for your shop. However, it won’t make you rank higher in search results.
SEO and Organic Traffic
Shopify SEO
You can get organic traffic from Google by optimizing your content for SEO. Use SEO best practices to write blog posts on your Shopify store and rank those posts on Google.
Another option to drive traffic from Google is by using Google Shopping, where you can list your products on Google Shopping (used to be free), and your product image, the price, and your brand name will appear on the first row of Google’s first page.
Etsy SEO
When you optimize your Etsy store and each of your Etsy listings for SEO, your product listings will start showing on Etsy search, allowing you to drive organic traffic from Etsy.
However, the one disadvantage of this is that for most of the profitable products sold on Etsy, the competition is very high, which results in your Etsy listing being pushed down unless you are one of the best sellers in your niche.
⇒ Best Etsy SEO Tools to Find Best Sellers!
Etsy also lists your products on Google via Etsy off-site Ads (Etsy charges you a fee only when someone clicks on your product and purchases it).
Another advertising option is Etsy Ads (on-site), which shows your product listing at the top of Etsy search results, and you pay for every click on your ad (whether they end up purchasing or not).
Etsy and Shopify Integration Options
Etsy Store Integrations
Using your Shop Manager, you can connect third-party tools to help with email marketing, Etsy SEO, and bookkeeping (like QuickBooks).
The options are minimal, especially compared to Shopify.
Shopify Store Integrations
Shopify allows you to connect thousands of apps through the Shopify App Store, giving you the opportunity to scale your business in ways Etsy simply can’t match.
Here’s how the Shopify App Store can transform your selling capabilities:
Email marketing: Send automated abandoned-cart emails and personalized product recommendations (when syncing with Klaviyo). Shopify also has its own built-in email marketing tool called Shopify Messaging.
Upsell and cross-sell apps: use AI to show personalized product recommendations and suggest complementary items to customers at checkout.
Shopify sellers get access to apps for everything—subscription management, SMS marketing, advanced analytics, social media automation, loyalty programs, and more.
The platform is built to grow with you as your business scales, giving you control over every aspect of your customer experience.
The Bottom Line: Shopify vs Etsy Pricing, Profits & Branding
Pricing & Profit
If you’re only planning to sell 1-2 products a month, Etsy would be the better choice financially. You’ll pay around 10% in combined fees per sale, but since you’re selling so little, those fees won’t add up to much compared to paying a monthly subscription.
However, if you’re planning to start a real ecommerce brand and turn it into a profitable business selling products consistently, paying approximately 10% per sale (before shipping costs) is going to cut into your profits tremendously—and it’s not going to be worth it in the long run.
Let me show you the math. When you’re making a few hundred or thousands in profit every month, it becomes much cheaper to pay the Shopify monthly fee and minimal transaction fees instead of giving up such a big chunk of every sale you make to Etsy fees.
How much does Shopify take from a $100 sale?
On Shopify’s Basic plan ($29/month when billed annually), you keep significantly more:
- Sale price: $100
- Credit card processing fee (2.9% + $0.30): $3.20
- You keep: $96.80
Compare that to Etsy on the same $100 sale:
- Sale price: $100
- Transaction fee (6.5%): $6.50
- Payment processing (3% + $0.25): $3.25
- Total fees: $9.75
- You keep: $90.25
That’s a $6.55 difference on just one sale. Now multiply that by 50 sales a month—you’re losing $327.50 in profit to Etsy fees alone.
With Shopify, you’d pay the $29 monthly fee plus processing fees, keeping way more of your hard-earned revenue.
Is It Risky to Sell on Etsy?
Beyond just fees, there are some serious long-term risks with building your business selling products exclusively on Etsy:
1. Etsy can shut down your store without warning
Etsy can suspend selling accounts for violations of its policies. This happens even to established sellers with thousands of sales, sometimes due to policy changes or algorithm errors.
If that occurs, you lose everything you’ve built for years because those customers were actually Etsy’s customers. You have no email list, no online presence outside Etsy and no social media following. Your business disappears overnight.
With Shopify, on the other hand, this is your website and your customer list. No one can shut it down and take away your customers. Shopify is a platform you control.
2. Reviews can damage your reputation permanently
Customers (or even competitors pretending to be customers) can leave bad reviews for your products, and you have no real control over them. That negative review can stay there forever on your listing, dragging down your average star rating and hurting future sales.
3. Phishing and hacker scams
Scammers impersonate Etsy employees through phishing emails or fake messages, claiming there’s suspicious activity on your account. If they succeed in gaining access, they can redirect your earnings to their bank account or lock you out of your own Etsy account.
The main difference between Etsy and platforms like Shopify is that on Shopify, as their ecommerce platform, you have more direct control over security and customer data.
Building Your Brand
Here’s where your long-term goals really matter.
If you want to build a successful brand with engaged followers on social media and a customer email list you can nurture every week, then Shopify is great for brands, no doubt about it.
Think of it like Shopify: you’re building your own store on the street with your name on the sign. You control the customer experience from start to finish. You decide how it looks, what promotions you run, and how you communicate with customers. Shopify allows you to build a recognizable brand that people remember and return to.
Whereas Etsy is a marketplace where you have a stall in a crowded market. Everyone’s competing side-by-side to win the same customer, and the main way to stand out is often by cutting prices, which is never good for profitability. You’re one of thousands selling similar products, and Etsy controls the rules of the game.
For beginners or people testing products, Etsy makes perfect sense. But if your business needs include scaling past a few hundred dollars a month, building brand loyalty, or creating a business you can eventually sell, advanced Shopify features give you the tools to do that.
The platform you choose should match where you are now and where you want to be in 2 years. Just remember, most successful online businesses eventually move to platforms like Shopify because it offers the control and scalability you need to grow into a real, lasting brand.
Start Selling and Build Your Online Business
So, Shopify or Etsy?
Here’s what it comes down to: both platforms will help you sell online, but they serve different purposes depending on where you are in your business journey.
For beginners or people testing products, Etsy makes perfect sense. It’s low-risk, easy to set up, and there are already millions of shoppers searching for what you’re selling. You can validate your products and start making money without a huge upfront investment.
But if your business needs include scaling past a few hundred dollars a month, building brand loyalty, collecting your own customer email list, or creating a business you can eventually sell, Shopify gives you the tools to do that. You own your store, your customer relationships, and your brand identity, and no one can take that away from you.
The platform you choose should match where you are now and where you want to be in two years. Just remember, most successful online businesses eventually move to platforms like Shopify because it offers the control and scalability you need to grow into a real, lasting brand.
Now it’s your turn. Pick the platform that fits your goals, start listing your first products, and build the online business you’ve been dreaming about.
This post may contain affiliate links, which means I’ll receive a commission if you purchase through one of my links at no extra cost to you! Thank you for supporting the Busy Mom Side Hustle blog. For more information, visit my disclaimer page.
